Background
Among one of the oldest law enforcement offices still in existence today is the office of the constable. The title of constable itself is derived from the root word comes stabuli or “Master of the Horse” or “Keeper of the King’s Stable”– a title traceable to the Roman and Byzantine Empires of the 5th century AD. While constables commonly held office throughout the annals of Western European history, their authority and role evolved considerably over time. For instance, the Constable of France maintained a military and judicial role during the medieval times, becoming “one of the five great officers of the state, with limited powers of jurisdiction and with command of the cavalry.” The constable’s role eventually rose to that of supreme military command of the French army by the mid-14th century. Following this rise in power, the role began to decline and was eventually eliminated by French Prime Minister Cardinal Richelieu in 1627, revived by Napoleon I in 1808, and then finally abolished upon the restoration of the Bourbons in 1814. The office of the constable in England was introduced following the Norman invasion of the British Isles in 1066, with its conquerors continuing the older Anglo-Saxon system of justice with few adaptations. Similar to France, constables in medieval England served as military officers in command of the army and controlled military garrisons and castles such as Windsor, Dover, and the infamous Tower of London. The English constable was originally a post in the royal court, however, by the late- 13th century, the constable had evolved into an officer of a manor, parish, or township, appointed by various local bodies such as courts, and ultimately subordinate to the sheriff or mayor. The constable’s primary duty was to keep peace and order in his specific shire or ward under the “watch-and-ward” system (guarding the city gates at night). Constables also provided security for traveling justices traversing the English countryside. According to the Statute of Winchester, (1285) – the codified legislation regulating local law enforcement in England, constables held the distinct authority to arrest suspicious strangers who would then be held and guarded until further investigation. Constables generally did not handle the investigation and prosecution of crimes in England, which were viewed as private matters to be handled by individual victims. When describing the duties of the constable, Henry de Bracton, well-known English jurist and clerk who wrote extensively between 1220 and 1250 wrote:
In whatever way and on whatever day, it is the duty of the constable to enroll everything in order, for he has record as to the things he sees; but he cannot judge, because there is no judgment at the Tower, since there the third element of a judicial proceeding is lacking, namely a judge and jurisdiction. He has record as to matters of fact, not matters of judgment and law.
According to Bracton’s writings, the English constable served as the “eyes and ears” of the court, finding evidence and recording facts upon which judges could make a ruling. By the 17th century, a high or chief constable was appointed in every locality and was responsible for suppressing riots and violent crimes, along with arming local militia to assist him. Petty constables began to serve under the high constable in each village. Both high and petty constables were viewed as executive legal officers of counties spread throughout England until the County Police Acts of 1839 and 1840 authorized certain local justices to establish paid police forces – a watershed development which gave rise to the country’s modern police system and led to the constable’s eventual reduction in rank and authority.
Constables are the oldest form of law enforcement officers in the recorded history of Pennsylvania. In fact, it is alleged that a constable was the first recorded law enforcement officer to be killed in action within Pennsylvania – the constable was killed in Venango County in 1825.416 According to early American records, constables first began serving Pennsylvania in the year 1664; a time when the Commonwealth was known as the colonial territory of “Penn’s Woods”. At this time, the office of constable was a close likeness to the office of constable in England. Constables were selected directly by the town’s people on a yearly basis alongside a board of overseers. The constitution and by-laws for each town “were framed by the constable and a majority of the board of overseers, and local observance became binding upon local inhabitants.” In addition, the constable and overseers served in a spiritual capacity, fulfilling the role of churchwardens, which were essentially the ecclesiastical governors and moral guardians of the parish or town. In this role, the constable assisted in the collection of local taxes or rates and was empowered to recover tax arrearages from those who failed to pay. Constables and overseers were also charged with notifying the semi-annual court of sessions of all unpunished transgressions of the town’s moral code. All of these duties added up to a much more principal purpose akin to that of constables in England: to preserve the peace of the community. The primary functions of the constable in Pennsylvania began to transform with the passage of time. A 1913 publication of Pennsylvania Justices’ Digest and Guide described the constabulary in the following way:
Every constable, of the Common Law is a conservator of the peace; and, as such, he may arrest those who the break the peace, confine them, bring them before a Justice to find surety or, he may himself take surety, when the breach is committed in his view. He is the proper executive hand of the Justice of the Peace, to serve his process and execute his lawful commands.
According to a previous 2014 report published by the Commission entitled Constables in Pennsylvania: Proposed Statutory Reforms, some researchers believe that the historical function of the constable as a peace officer had virtually been replaced in Pennsylvania by the mid-20th century by a much more commercial function. The Commission’s report linked this assumption to a combination of factors, including the reality that “arresting criminal offenders is likely more unpleasant and more dangerous than performing the duties that are commercial in nature.” Furthermore, the report suggested that the creation of municipal police departments among townships and boroughs may also partially explain the reason behind its functional transformation. More contemporary functions of the Pennsylvania constable have included the service of process for district courts and the levy and execution of judgments. Constables have also aided “in the collection of small claims too minor to interest an attorney and in the enforcement of landlords’ remedies against delinquent tenants.” Today a constable is an elected officer, independent of both the judiciary and the municipality in which he or she has been elected. In fact, constables are essentially independent contractors, subject to no direct, routine, or formal oversight.
Legal Authority
Foundational legal authority for the office of constable and its deputies can be found in Chapter 71 under Title 44 (Law and Justice) of Pennsylvania’s Consolidated Statutes. This chapter covers definitions pertinent to the office, election requirements, appointment, conflicts, training, powers and duties, compensation, and relevant penalties and remedies.425 However, there are many other state statutes in addition to Chapter 71 referencing constables and the performance of their duties. In addition, a growing thicket of court precedence established over time has helped to supplement the constabulary’s statutory authority.
Appointing Authority
As mentioned previously, the office of constable is not an appointed position. Rather, the office of constable is generally an elected position that spans a term of six years within any city of the second class, city of the second class A, city of the third class, borough, incorporated town, or township. In cities of the second and third class, qualified voters for each individual ward situated within the city elects a constable for each of their respective wards. The same is true for a borough that is divided by wards, however, the qualified electorate in a borough also votes for a high constable for the overall borough in addition to the constables of each individual ward. In 1970, the office of constable was abolished under Pennsylvania law for cities of the first class.
The office of constable only becomes an appointed position in Pennsylvania when a vacancy occurs. In the event of a vacancy, for any reason, the court of common pleas of the county of the vacancy, upon petition of not less than ten qualified electors residing in the borough, city, ward, or township of the vacancy, appoints a suitable individual, “who, upon being qualified as required by law, shall serve as the constable for the unexpired term of the vacancy.